Ä¢¹½¶ÌÊÓÆµ

Skip to main content

Latest news

17
November
2026
|
14:42
Europe/London

Talking in categories, and why that doesn’t work

Ìýreflects on their research and how lived experience has become a popular method for policymakers and researchers seeking to address inequality. However, people’s experiences are often treated as ‘categories’ or ‘issues’, which can put mental health into a box separate from homelessness, or food inequalities as separate to disability. Yet people do not live their lives in these separate boxes.Ìý

Download

Equally, people’s lives cannot be treated as raw ‘data’ to be taken away by researchers and policymakers for interpretation. The activity of sharing lived experience already involves critical and creative acts of interpretation. Similarly, the work that people are already doing to survive, enact care, and create change needs to be acknowledged.

Community organisations often bring people together to reflect across different backgrounds and experiences.

Community organisations often bring people together to reflect across different backgrounds and experiences, for example in the work of Poverty Truth Community in Glasgow. Such dialogue can develop critical consciousness by understanding lived experience as relational and community-oriented rather than individualistic. This draws on liberationist traditions, including Paulo Freire and Patricia Hill Collins, which have also influenced my work in practical theology and liberationist ethics, where social change is understood as rooted in community praxis and critical engagement with lived experience.Ìý

From prior projects with Poverty Truth groups in Glasgow and Ä¢¹½¶ÌÊÓÆµ, we wanted a project that started with an emphasis not on categories, but with the everyday creativity and knowledge in communities that comes from navigating inequalities and creating change together.Ìý

Collaboration Through the ProjectÌý

We started with a small steering group of participants from Poverty Truth groups in Glasgow and Greater Ä¢¹½¶ÌÊÓÆµ to plan the focus of the research. As this was during the Covid-19 pandemic, we had to think about the practical issues as well as ethical concerns about research during a difficult time.ÌýÌý

We settled on sending out creative journaling packs with prompts, alongside inviting people to join weekly reflection workshops in small groups. During these reflection sessions, we would talk about how people’s week had been, alongside trying short reflective activities and sharing back what we had done. There was a lot of laughter, emotional discussion, encouragement, and understanding each other (and ourselves!) better. These communal spaces also shaped how people developed their creative journal, as often people would take inspiration from something in the group and then add that to their journal. The creative journal was a space where people could write, draw, collage, paint, or stick in photographs – whatever was best for them! Each journal was very different based on how that person reflected, how they understood and interacted with the world.ÌýÌýÌý

At the end of the project, we wanted to be able to share thisÌýprocessÌýof reflecting together on varied experiences and this approach to creatively engaging experiences of inequality together. The output shares digital recreations of creative pieces from the workshops and journals. Importantly, this keeps together a variety of different people’s experiences, as well as showing the range of experiences and insights from individuals. As noted at the beginning of Filled to the Brim:Ìý

we also knowÌý
our lives areÌý
many, multiple, tangled, true
full of contrasts and contradictions
difficulty, but beauty in betweenÌý
Ìý
we can’t be boiled down
reduced to an essence
an issue
a budget
a headline
a talking point
an agenda
Ìý
we peeked under the surface of what is ordinary
even mundane
reflected on what might pass you byÌý
and we found it filled to the brim

Ìý

Why Creative Reflection on Everyday Inequalities?Ìý

Providing space to reflect together on everyday life enabled us as a group to dig into things that are often seen as too ordinary or too complex to show up in research, policy, and campaigning.ÌýÌý

The time over many sessions enabled a building of relationships where people could share and listen in ways that mattered to them. As one person put it, the groups exemplified ‘difference, but resonance’, a space to recognise solidarity across distinct experiences. Recognising the individual particularity and the communal element of this work is significant as it recognises that experiences are not easily extractable points but are embedded in relational networks of families, communities, and societies.Ìý

We also aimed to focus on what people were already doing to survive and create change in their ordinary lives as part of that complexity of experience. Lots of actions of ordinary care showed up in the reflections, but also the exhausting challenges of caring for oneself and others in systems and societies that often reinforce stigma and harm.

Whilst often called ‘lived’ experiences, they are not always ‘past tense’ but often areÌýlivingÌýexperiences in the present tense. Even prior experiences areÌýliveÌýin the way they shift and change as people look back and weave them into their present understandings. No-one should feel that they must share difficulties in their life publicly, and it is important to remember that not everything can be put easily into words. One person wrote:

My mind is all mineÌý
My thoughts and feelings I don’t usually shareÌý
They are mine
To be fair

Ìý

Another person sent back a blank journal as a powerful reminder that they could not put down their experiences in black and white because they risked being ‘not just misunderstood but un-understood’. We kept these blank spaces in Filled to the Brim as a reminder to readers of this challenge.Ìý

Creative reflection creates space to share experiences without the pressure to turn themÌýinto something ‘useful’ for research, policy, or action. It also reminds us that we can never fully understand another person’s experiences. As people continue to live, change, and create, we must keep listening to those who are most affected by inequality. Ìý

Doing Research DifferentlyÌý

Whilst ‘impact’ is often understood as academic research impacting local communities, academic and policy researchÌýcanÌýandÌýshould beÌýshaped by communities who are already seeking to address the inequalities that they experience. This is a long-term and often slow process, one that needs time, energy, and understanding to develop relationships. Community organisations and projects often work at a different pace than dictated by academic deadlines. Sometimes research responses need to be more immediate and urgent, at other times being respectful how long people have already been raising issues, supporting one another, and how long it may take to create lasting change.Ìý

Humanities research at its best can be part of making a more just society. Yet, to do so, research and researchers also need to be open to having their practices and priorities impacted in the process.Ìý

Share this page